best butt plugs

5 Best Butt Plugs for Comfort & Pleasure (Expert Advice)

If you have an interest in sex toys, chances are you have seen or have heard about butt plugs. Have you ever wondered what draws someone to an anal plug and the pleasure that can be found with these items? If you are new to such toys or are curious about anal play, we are excited to share more information on butt plugs for beginners, as well as guide you towards the best butt plugs available on the market.

Whether you're looking for a beginner butt plug or a more advanced sex toy that offers anal stimulation, butt plugs provide an easy introduction to anal play. While some people may have reservations about inserting an item into their butt, there are many variations available that make using a butt plug comfortable and safe. Best of all, butt plugs are great for all bodies and all gender identities. Just like opinions, everyone has a butt!

What Are Butt Plugs?

glass anal plug

In essence, butt plugs are sex toys that are inserted into the rectum. Similar to dildos, plugs offer a smooth design with a rounded tip for a more comfortable entry. However, unlike dildos, butt plus are shorter and often wider, offering a flared base so that it does not get lost inside the rectum. If you're looking for an introduction to anal play or anal depth training, toys such as butt plugs are an excellent option for beginners.

Addressing Concerns

There are several misconceptions around anal play, and as such, many people are nervous about putting anal toys in their butt. Concerns over safety, cleanliness, and even pain are definitely valid. But with the proper information and education and by investing in the best butt plug to suit your needs and experience level, anal stimulation can be very enjoyable and completely safe.

With any intimate object that goes inside your body, it's extremely important to practice proper cleaning and hygiene. Also, self-awareness and exercising patience is essential. Unlike the vagina, the rectum is not as flexible or stretchy, so one must take precautions with anal play to not tear the delicate tissues. The key is to start with small butt plugs and work your way up to a larger size.

Also, penetration should be slow and measured, regularly checking in with yourself or your partner to ensure comfort. Particularly with anal sex and women, stimulation of the clitoris (look at some clitoris pumps) might be helpful in creating more pleasure as you insert a butt plug.

Is There a Difference Between Butt Plugs for Men and a Butt Plug for Women?

When it comes to sexual activity, anal play is a great equalizer. As mentioned, regardless of your gender identity, everyone has a butt, anus, and rectum. So by that logic, there is no real difference in butt plugs between men and women.

That said, men may have a slight advantage over women when it comes to this inclusive sex toy. Because men possess a prostate gland, wearing a butt plug can offer prostate stimulation, which can provide continuous and enjoyable sensations. The best way for men to experience prostate pleasure is through wearing the plug, as it rubs against the gland.

Challenging Societal Norms

Historically, when it comes to male-identified folks and anal penetration, most types of anal play have been subject to discrimination and have even resulted in laws that prohibit anal sex between men. In turn, this has created a judgemental attitude towards men's sexuality.

Using a butt plug has nothing to do with sexual orientation, but some people believe that if a man inserts an anal plug into their butt, they must be gay. Such limiting and critical beliefs have resulted in many men dismissing sex toys such as butt plugs for fear that they would be judged harshly.

However, this is a ridiculous notion, and luckily, we are moving into a time of greater sexual education and freedom around bodies and pleasure. Make no 'butts' about it; prostate pleasure is attainable and enjoyable regardless of your sexual preference.

The Female Esthetic and The A-Spot

While the overall shape of butt plugs generally remains consistent, manufacturers may market to anal toys and plugs a bit differently to women.

Butt plugs that are designed for a female-identified audience may include such features as jeweled ends or cute and furry tails. The colors of the plugs may come in more feminine tones, such as pink or purple. Sometimes, women may even use this versatile sex toy as a cute accessory!

Where women lack a prostate gland (or 'P-Spot'), they make up with an 'A-Spot'. The 'A-Spot' is a pleasure center that is found deep inside the vagina, between the cervix and the bladder. It is approximately two inches higher than the G-Spot and is considered the 'female prostate' as it is located in a similar place in the body, where the prostate gland is found in men.

Using a butt plug-either on its own or particularly during anal sex-can help to stimulate the A-spot. This can lead to some of the best orgasms and sometimes even female ejaculation!

But at the end of the day, a butt is a butt, and prostate stimulation aside, any gender can enjoy the thrills that come with toys, such as butt plugs.

What Are Butt Plugs Made Of?

Like most sex toys, butt plugs come in a variety of materials. However, the best butt toys are made from body-safe components, especially when it comes to anal enjoyment. 

Silicone is one of the best materials for butt plugs and most intimate toys because it is hypoallergenic and quite soft and smooth. Silicone toys are also easy to clean; simply submerge into boiling water to disinfect your anal plug. Silicone plugs offer comfort, which will increase enjoyment while wearing the toy.

However, butt plugs also come in metal, glass, wood, stone, stainless steel; you can even find glass butt plugs. That said, sex toys, in general, are moving away from using plastic, and that also applies to anal plugs.

What is the Difference Between Plugs and Anal Beads?

It's easy to see the similarities between plugs and anal beads. However, the main difference is that anal beads are generally used as an accessory during sex. In contrast, butt plugs can be inserted and left inside the butt over a period of time.

Anal beads are said to increase the sensation and intensity of orgasms. On the other hand, butt plugs offer enjoyment and pleasure while worn a la carte! Butt plugs can also be worn discreetly underneath clothing, whereas anal beads are typically used during sexual activity.

Are Vibrating Anal Plugs Safe?

Vibrating butt plugs are a fun alternative for those who enjoy a more intense form of stimulation. Because the anus has so many nerve endings, plugs that offer vibrations can offer loads of pleasure. In addition, stirring up these nerve endings can make inserting your butt plug easier, especially for beginners.

In general, a butt plug that vibrates is as safe as a regular, non-vibrating plug. That said, one should exercise the same precautions, regardless of what type of butt plug you use. Also, make sure that you are careful when cleaning the vibrating butt plug. Some models may not be submersible in water, so be careful to read the label and instructions.

With vibrating toys, you should also experiment with the various speeds; go slow and be gentle.

How Does A Butt Plug Work?

If you are unfamiliar with anal play, using a plug may seem strange. However, many people are curious about how a butt plug can provide erotic sensations in the body.

As mentioned above, butt plugs can provide arousal of the prostate gland (in men) and the A-Spot (in women), as well as exciting the sensitive nerve clusters around the anus. When used during sex, various positions will enhance the use of the plug, hitting the pressure points in all of the right ways!

It should also be noted that orgasms begin with contractions of the pelvic floor muscles. When you wear a butt plug, the anal muscles will push against the plug, making your orgasms feel more intense.

How To Insert A Butt Plug

If you are new to plugs, chances are you are concerned about comfort. Since it's less often that we insert items into our rectum, there is a misconception that the introduction of an anal toy could hurt. However, inserting a butt plug need not be painful; in fact, it's not supposed to be! 

For first-timers, we recommend inserting a butt plug by yourself first so that you can become more familiar with the process and the sensations.

First, always make sure that your toy has a flared base. Second, with all of the different sizes available, ensure that you choose a comfortable shape; never force a butt plug that is too large. And third, always use a copious amount of lube. When it comes to butt toys, you can never use enough lube!

Are Butt Plugs Easy To Clean?

It's crucial that you keep your intimate toys in the best shape possible, and of course, that means ensuring that your plug is kept clean. You should always wash your toys before inserting them into your body, each and every time, even if you are the only person who is using the plug. 

Porous Plugs

To wash a plug that is made of more porous material like plastic, jelly, or nylon, thoroughly clean with soap and water. However, with porous plugs, do not wash them immediately after use as bacteria from insertion could linger on the toy. Also, be sure not to scrub a porous toy clean so that you can avoid germs from entering a scratched surface. 

Non-Porous Material

Toys made of non-porous material, such as stainless steel, glass, or silicone, are easy to clean and disinfect. If the fabric of your toy is made from heat-resistant materials, you can dunk them in boiling water for ten minutes. 

However, if the substance is not as heat-resistant, such as medical-grade silicone, you can clean them with warm, antibacterial soap and water, just as you would with toys made of porous materials. 

How To Choose The Right Anal Plug

jeweled butt plug

As you begin your search for the perfect anal plug, how do you know which is the best butt plug for you? In addition to plugs made of various materials, like stainless steel, there are also different sizes and designs to choose from.

In general, there are three different shapes that you can explore; a classic model, plugs that offer decorative ends, such as tails or jewels, or a vibrating plug. Your choice just comes down to what you're looking for in terms of anal pleasure and stimulation.

Regardless of how you choose, it's essential to keep these points in mind:

  • Make sure you are feeling relaxed and aroused prior to use.
  • Always use a toy with a flared base.
  • Start small and work your way up to a larger size.
  • Try experimenting with vibrations for additional stimulation.
  • Always use lots of lube. For toys made of silicone, ensure that you use a water-based lube.

Recommendations of the Best Butt Plugs

We researched some of the best butt plugs available on the market. Check out some of our favorite models to see which might be best for you.

1. njoy Plure Plug Medium Stainless Steel

njoy Pure Plug Medium Stainless Steel Butt Plug

We love the gorgeous design of this luxurious, high-end plug! This item measures 3.5 inches in length and 3.9 inches in circumference. The njoy anal plug is made entirely from non-porous stainless steel, with a weight of 200 grams. The tapered front end and smooth flared base offer comfort upon insertion, with just enough pressure from the metal to offer delicious sensations and stimulation.

One aspect that we love about stainless steel is that you can explore temperature play with your plug. Simply store in the fridge to cool or submerge in hot water to heat the toy. This high-end model may be on the pricier side, but considering its quality, it's an investment worth considering.

Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug

Put your beginner toy jitters 'behind you' and get ready to explore introductory anal pleasure with this adorable, jeweled model. The 2.5-inch length and the 1.45-gram weight are suitable for those who are new to plugs. This fabulous-looking plug comes in nickel-free zinc-alloy metal, which is perfect for all skin types, especially those who may experience more sensitivity.

Like the njoy model, this item is also excellent for temperature play; we recommend trying different temperatures to see what you may like best! The jeweled end offers security that the toy will stay in place, but this plug also adds a bit of exciting flare. This particular plug is quite affordable, making it a great introductory toy for those who are new to this type of sex toy.

Lovehoney Butt Tingler 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug

Make no 'butts' about it; this vibrating plug provides incredible stimulation, wrapped up in a sexy design. The body-safe silicone material is easy to clean, and the T-Bar shaped base offers comfort and peace of mind. The 4.5-inch width will create a feeling of 'fullness,' which is often enjoyed by many.

The source of the tingles come from a small bullet vibrator that can be removed from the base. This option allows you to explore the plug, with or without the bullet. But with three different speeds and seven vibration patterns, you may be curious to enjoy stimulating your most sensitive areas. This inexpensive model offers incredible value, along with quality craftsmanship.

Lelo Hugo SenseMotion Remote Control Rechargeable Prostate Massager

Attention people with prostate glands-this plug is for you! Lelo is well-known for its high-end sex toys, and their plugs are no different. This is an incredible toy for both beginners and more experienced users. It's made from medical-grade silicone, which offers supreme softness and comfort. The slight curvature was explicitly created to stimulate the P-spot. Enjoy the erotic vibrations from two twin motors built inside the product.

We love the Lelo model's versatility and the fact that you can use it for both solo and partner play. If you are looking for a way to involve your lover, simply hand over the remote and allow them to tease you for hours! Or you can insert the plug and experience it simultaneously while you engage in intimacy with your partner.

Lelo products are quite expensive, but if you are looking for a quality item that will a long time, we recommend considering this model.

Lovehoney Full Bloom Large Rose Glass Butt Plug

Treat your ass to some class with a beautiful plug made of glass! Toys made from glass are easy to clean and disinfect and excellent material for temperature play. Glass plugs can be paired with any type of lubricant. We recommend using a silicone-based lube for intimate products that are not made of silicone because it's the longer-lasting formula.

This model is great for beginners, especially those who want to expand to accommodate larger toys eventually. We absolutely love the rose; it's a pretty accessory that also keeps the plug securely in place.


In reviewing the best butt plugs from leading manufacturers, we recommend the Lovehoney Butt Tingler Vibrating PlugWe believe that every bum should be treated to fun, vibrating sensations, and this silicone beauty is both safe and comfortable. Plus, the price reflects both quality and value.